New Voice Media | Associated Baptist Press
     
 
Thursday, March 18, 2010
Home arrow News arrow Opinion: Great awakening versus cultural captivity
 
Opinion: Great awakening versus cultural captivity Print E-mail
By Marv Knox   
Tuesday, November 10, 2009

(ABP) -- If -- as some observers claim -- flames of spiritual awakening are fanning across the globe, then why have they seemingly lept over the United States?

Titles of two great books provide a clue: At Ease in Zion by Rufus Spain and Churches in Cultural Captivity by John Lee Eighmy. These classic volumes cannot be summarized in just one paragraph. But it’s fair to say they address a vital question: Since the South was dominated by pious, church-going Baptists, why did it remain a regressive backwater, where human rights, justice and personal liberty stagnated for a century following the Civil War? The answer lay within the tight parameters by which provincial Baptists proscribed their faith. They measured themselves by narrow pieties -- in those days, refraining from liquor, illicit sex and gambling -- and failed to ponder the broader realm of moral rectitude. In fact, as far as justice and civil righteousness were concerned, they merely copied the selfish concerns of their surrounding culture.

The more things change, the more they stay the same. Oh, we may be “right” on race now (although, were it not for black Baptists and liberal mainline Protestants, one could doubt racial attitudes would have changed a smidge). But the church in America -- not merely Baptists -- continues to be defined by what it is not instead of by what it is. So we decry the horrors of crime, the media’s glamorization of sex and violence, and the dangers of substance abuse, gay marriage and abortion.

Unfortunately, the church in America -- particularly Baptists, mainliners and evangelicals -- still mirrors its surrounding culture. We’re no less consumed by materialism than are our communities. Most of the time, we handle authority and power no better than the businesses, schools and governments nearby. In fact, we often handle power worse than other institutions. For example, our conflict-management processes typically look more like no-holds-barred political grudge matches than opportunities for Christians to practice redemption and restoration.

What’s more, as individual Christians, we’re doing no better than our churches. Except that we’re programmed to say the right things, and the most vocal and/or active among us protest gay marriage and abortion, we offer little evidence that what happens in our church buildings on Sunday morning makes any difference in our lives on Tuesday night or Thursday afternoon. We lust for power just like the next gal. We’re just as seduced by things as the next guy. Our marriages fail and we lie at about the same pace as everybody else. We have the same problems with our kids as our neighbors do.

And we’re comfortable with it. If we weren’t, we’d do something about it. We’d change. We’re a church at ease in secular society; we’re captive to our culture.

This opinion piece is packaged -- in Associated Baptist Press and its New Voice Media partners the Texas Baptist Standard, the Virginia Baptist Religious Herald and the Missouri Baptist Word & Way -- with a group of articles on spiritual awakening. I hope you’ll read it. I particularly resonate with an observation made by Jim Denison: Awakening doesn’t happen until Christians get desperate. We can spiritualize that idea, but it tracks basic human nature. People don’t change deep habits, addictions, customs or beliefs until they finally realize something’s wrong and they get desperate for difference.

Spiritual awakening is bypassing America because we’re comfortable in our consumeristic, class-driven culture. Nothing’s likely to change until we get fed up and desire change more than comfort and security. Many Christians have been fretting about the future, and mostly what they mention is the economy -- their financial future. While no sane person would desire fiscal calamity, spiritual poverty is more serious than financial fragility. Likewise, while my theology doesn’t allow me to believe God causes an economic depression, God certainly can use one to achieve broader and deeper purposes.

-30-

This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it   is editor of the Baptist Standard.

 

EDITORIAL DISCLAIMER: As part of our mission to provide credible and compelling information about matters of faith, Associated Baptist Press actively seeks a diversity of viewpoints in its columns, commentaries and other opinion-based content. Opinions expressed in these articles are not intended to represent ABP editorial policy and do not necessarily reflect the views of ABP’s staff, board of directors or supporters.

 





Reddit!Del.icio.us!Google!Live!Facebook!Slashdot!Technorati!StumbleUpon!Spurl!Newsvine!Blinklist!Furl!Fark!Yahoo!Ma.gnolia!Free social bookmarking plugins and extensions for Joomla! websites!
Comments (6)Add Comment
Its About God
written by Mark Osgatharp, November 10, 2009
While Mr. Knox laments certain aspects of social sins, he, in his recent infamous editorial on same gender "marriage" said the he wasn't sure it was sinful, though he thought it might be. He has, therefore, rendered himself incredible as a commentator on spirituality or morality, seeing his own philosophy is morally ambiguous.

That notwithstanding, all of man's moral failings, whether socially or individually, are the result of one thing and one thing only - a failure to believe God.

The Jews in Old Testament times, though given a royal law on a silver platter, did not believe God and were consequently decimated as a nation, as were all the nations around them. The Pharisees and Sadducees, though at odds theologically and yet both intensely religious, did not believe God, as evidenced by the fact that they crucified Him. The ancient Gentile world was engrossed in wickedness because they did not believe God.

Whatever problems our American forefathers, or our European, African or Asian forefathers before them, or we ourselves have experienced, we have experienced because we don't believe God. We say we believe God, but the god we believe in is a god of our own making - not the God heaven and of the Lord Jesus Christ.

The only remedy for sin, which will never be experienced on a national scale but will always be experienced on a personal and limited corporate scale, is to repent and believe God. There just isn't too much of that going on today....probably never was or never will be.

The words of Jesus come to mind,

"Broad is the gate....."

Mark Osgatharp
Wynne, Arkansas
Marv is right...culture matters
written by Xenophon, November 12, 2009
Marv writes: "Unfortunately, the church in America -- particularly Baptists, mainliners and evangelicals -- still mirrors its surrounding culture. We’re no less consumed by materialism than are our communities. Most of the time, we handle authority and power no better than the businesses, schools and governments nearby. In fact, we often handle power worse than other institutions. For example, our conflict-management processes typically look more like no-holds-barred political grudge matches than opportunities for Christians to practice redemption and restoration...We lust for power just like the next gal. We’re just as seduced by things as the next guy. Our marriages fail and we lie at about the same pace as everybody else. We have the same problems with our kids as our neighbors do. And we’re comfortable with it. If we weren’t, we’d do something about it. We’d change. We’re a church at ease in secular society; we’re captive to our culture."

All of this is true and very insightful. Culture has a tremendous ability to shape our consciousness in the broadest sense of the word that includes the unconscious. In fact, the main way that culture affects people is by unconscious or marginally conscious influences.
Novelist Tom Wolfe relies on social psychological studies to suggest that people take in through their senses unfiltered what they are exposed to constantly in daily life that then stirs their para-sympathetic nervous system. At that point much of the battle is lost. Impulses present themselves to the will that we have to power to deny, but given our frailty, it is increasingly difficult to resist the barrage of stimulation. Wolfe fictionalizes where these bio-psycho-social processes in his novel, *I am Charlotte Simmons,* that follows how a socially conservative coed falls prey to the sexual revolution on a major college campus (reportedly it is Duke University that is modeled in the novel). Below is a lecture where Wolfe lays the basis of his novel out very clearly. Incidentally, Wolfe also points to another truth in this lecture that people are always pushing their group to get ahead of the others in a never-ending competition for social status.

http://www.neh.gov/whoweare/wolfe/lecture.html

I am afraid that Marv is right to pinpoint one of the main reasons for this drift is the very success of our economic system that has fanned our innate greed without providing the containing and sublimating channels to properly harness the coarse energy that the lures of economic gain ignites in people. What culture can do is provide these channels and edges that is needed to direct the flow of vital forces that move us to act. Culture gives definition to our instincts as it opens some outlets and closes off others. Culture provides the practices that habitually shape our bodily movements and our thoughts that facilitates the possibility of opening ourselves up to each other and to God. The way of life that we are immersed in structures and solidifies our soul.

God can and does reach people in non-Christian cultures and he might very well allow us to return to being a minority in a pagan culture (and I mean pagan as in polytheism, divination, etc.) to revitalize our reliance on God alone uprooting us from this decadent culture that has drifted away from him. But the way that people usually come to know Jesus as Savior is by being born into a Christian family and culture. Renewal comes through individuals who have been born again who form social patterns as they act in concert with others who are moved by the Holy Spirit in their daily lives that then open others up to the love of Christ. The corruptive process that we are currently in the midst of can be reversed by the renewing of our minds and hearts in Christ as we are indwelt with the vitality of the Holy Spirit who motivates us to act on our faith.
...
written by Jesdisciple, November 13, 2009
While Mr. Knox laments certain aspects of social sins, he, in his recent infamous editorial on same gender "marriage" said the he wasn't sure it was sinful, though he thought it might be. He has, therefore, rendered himself incredible as a commentator on spirituality or morality, seeing his own philosophy is morally ambiguous.

To the contrary, that renders him a credible scholar because he admits his uncertainty. If you aren't uncertain about any important theological issue, I would suggest listening to more people who disagree with you.

I have reviewed some of the reasons for denying the sinfulness homosexuality, and I don't think they're credible (though I wouldn't call them absurd). However, discounting credibility based on uncertainty without knowing that the reason for uncertainty is absurd is - well, absurd.

As to the article, I agree. I often get so comfortable in bed that when the alarm rings I would much rather not get up; I used to not even hear it. I've broken this habit in cases where I have an obligation, but I often sleep in otherwise. I think America is too comfortable to hear the commotion around the world and the voices screaming at us to WAKE UP!
...
written by Jesdisciple, November 13, 2009
Oops, I forgot to quote that first paragraph.
Certainty
written by Mark Osgatharp, November 13, 2009
Jesdisciple,

Are you certain about all that? ;0)

Your musings expose the fundamental difference between Christianity and modernism - between faith and unbelief. Jesus often said,

"Verily, verily I say unto you."

Paul said,

"Whereunto I am ordained a preacher, and an apostle, (I speak the truth in Christ, and lie not;) a teacher of the Gentiles in faith and verity."

Faith believes God. Doubt questions God. Sin is the fruit of doubt for "whatsoever is not of faith is sin." Righteousness is the fruit of faith for, "the just shall live by faith."

Mark Osgatharp
Wynne, Arkansas
Socialism = Evangelism?
written by Bobby McCord, December 03, 2009
According to this writer, the church is not growing and thriving because we do not practice socialism? I am amazed at the logic liberals live out of. Let the government take all of our freedoms and money and faith and somehow the church will grow. I do believe the church does grow when faced with great persecution but that doesn't mean I am praying for persecution. If you are worried about people and their health care, Help them, don't hire the government to seize funds from the working to support those who refuse to work. That mentality will be the down fall of this nation.

Readers alone are responsible for the content of the comments they post here. The comments are subject to the site’s terms and conditions of use and do not necessarily reflect the opinion or approval of the ABP News. Readers whose comments violate the terms of use may have their comments removed or all of their content blocked from viewing by other users without notification.
Write comment
You must be logged in to leave a comment. Login | Register
busy
 
< Prev   Next >
Copyright © 2007-2010 Associated Baptist Press, All Rights Reserved.