New Voice Media | Associated Baptist Press
     
 
Wednesday, March 17, 2010
Home arrow Opinion arrow Opinion: Giving thanks in a troubled land
 
Opinion: Giving thanks in a troubled land Print E-mail
By David Gushee   
Monday, November 23, 2009

(ABP) -- Thanksgiving week is upon us. The annual celebration centered on gratitude for God’s blessings -- for our nation, for family and all other good gifts -- comes to a troubled, hungry, divided nation this year.

Thanksgiving was originally a harvest festival. It still conjures up images of abundant material blessings in a fruitful land. Those with means still gather around tables groaning under the weight of turkey, stuffing, cranberry sauce and pumpkin pie.

But while our farms are still fruitful, our economic system today leaves out fully one-sixth of all Americans. A recent study placed the number of Americans facing “food insecurity” at 49 million. Another study suggests that the real unemployment and underemployment rate stands at 17.5 percent. Both measures point to a staggering fact: At least one-sixth of all Americans are in serious financial trouble. That’s five students in a classroom of thirty, 50 people in a congregation of 300.

Much of the legislative year has been consumed in a fight over the expansion of health care to a large portion of the American population that does not have adequate access. Thanksgiving will come this year to a nation in which one-third of all Americans lacked health insurance at some point in the last two years, with 46 million lacking health coverage for the entirety of a year. There’s that number again -- just under 50 million, or one-sixth of the population, left out of America’s bounty.

Thanksgiving comes this year with Congress closer to passing health-care reform than ever before. Having turned aside one filibuster effort already, the Senate will soon enter into debate on the legislation, a version of which already passed the House. Neither the Senate nor the House legislation has attracted Republican support, with a few tiny exceptions. It is hard for me to imagine that history will judge this Republican foot-dragging any more kindly than it judges similar foot-dragging related to Medicare in 1965 or Franklin Roosevelt’s Depression-fighting efforts in the 1930s.

But even if the legislation does pass, it is now increasingly clear that finding ways to generate meaningful and lasting employment for 50 million Americans is the deeper issue. Apparently some kind of second-round stimulus or jobs legislation will be offered early in 2010 by the Democrat-led Congress. It may be that such an effort would help in the short term. But the deeper issues with the economy have to do with the competitiveness of the United States and our workforce vis-à-vis other nations. We need far more than a short-term band-aid in the form of a jobs package paid for with more borrowed money. We need well-educated workers and innovative companies creating products that the entire world wants -- as we so often have done in the past.

One place to generate such economic energy is in the “green jobs” sector. Those nations and companies that develop products to support environmentally sustainable economic growth will be huge winners in the 21st century. Right now, it is not at all clear that the United States will lead the way in green jobs as we have so many other new economic sectors in the past century. This has much to do with our national sluggishness in recognizing the extent of our world’s ecological challenges.

Our pastor this past Sunday introduced the holiday season, in part, by expressing concern for those for whom the holidays are a source of pain rather than joy. There are many reasons why Thanksgiving and Christmas would be painful rather than joyful for some people, but the epidemic of family breakdown is probably the major source. Only half of American adolescents live with both biological parents, the result of negative long-term trends in out-of-wedlock birth rates and divorce. Thanksgiving this year will find millions of children and adults trying to navigate the enormous and painful complexities created by their fragmented and fragile families. Social-science research clearly shows the negative impact of family disruption on adolescent behavior patterns.

Some kids start off life in our brutally constricted economy at a serious disadvantage due to the chaos in their family lives. We must do better than this. Legislation has little contribution to make here. It’s a battle, one marriage and one family at a time.

When my tribe gathers around the Thanksgiving table on Thursday it will be the first time we have all been together for a long time. I will be grateful to God for many, many blessings. But the gratitude will be shadowed by thoughts of neighbors who are not so fortunate this Thanksgiving Day.

-30-

David Gushee is distinguished university professor of Christian ethics at Mercer University. 

 

EDITORIAL DISCLAIMER: As part of our mission to provide credible and compelling information about matters of faith, Associated Baptist Press actively seeks a diversity of viewpoints in its columns, commentaries and other opinion-based content. Opinions expressed in these articles are not intended to represent ABP editorial policy and do not necessarily reflect the views of ABP’s staff, board of directors or supporters.

 





Reddit!Del.icio.us!Google!Live!Facebook!Slashdot!Technorati!StumbleUpon!Spurl!Newsvine!Blinklist!Furl!Fark!Yahoo!Ma.gnolia!Free social bookmarking plugins and extensions for Joomla! websites!
Comments (19)Add Comment
Foot Dragging
written by tenor1, November 23, 2009
Quoth Dr. Gushee: "It is hard for me to imagine that history will judge this Republican foot-dragging any more kindly than it judges similar foot-dragging related to Medicare in 1965 or Franklin Roosevelt’s Depression-fighting efforts in the 1930s."
I believe history records that FDR's depression-fighting efforts only prolonged the depression, and like the current administration's policy that government can spend its way out of recession/depression, it is again exacerbating the problem. Only this time it is deliberate, by this administration whose goal was to achieve unemployment levels like those of Europe at 10% or more. Now, more people can line up at the government trough and be fed and be thankful.
Social Security and Medicare, both products of socialism's finest hours, are flat broke and are about to be even broker. If this God-awful healthscare plan becomes law, a third of doctors could find it convenient to retire or leave practice due to Obama-promised further cuts in Medicare funding. Add to that 40 million more patients and the prospects are frightening. I am still paying over $3000 per year for healthcare insurance with prospects for MUCH HIGHER rates in order for us to have "affordable" health care.
Yes, Dr Gushee, history will look upon the ashes of the once greatest Republic civilization has ever known, and record that this nation bankrupted itself and totally imploded under the mistaken notion that bigger government could create a world utopia, where only the "rich" would pay all the bills, and where there was social justice all around. But when there were no more "rich", and the well ran dry, and the people were still lined up the government feed trough, an ancient truth became again apparant: THERE IS NO FREE LUNCH!
Do you really believe?
written by richardsondad, November 24, 2009
Dr. Gushee,
Do you really believe that the health care reform will create coverage for all those who do not have it? I do not. I belive it will create longer waits for treatment, panels of experts deciding who can and cannot get medicine and fewer trained health care professionals because the rewards for hard work and dedication are no longer there. For historical perspective, please note how the government has run Medicare and Social Security.

Where is the money going to come from? I think the money will come from those of us currently have jobs and have insurance. And it will come from those who have enough money to create those green jobs you speak of.

And those green jobs will never be created because that money will be sent to the government. And more of us will be unemployed or pushed to the point of "food insecurity".

I don't believe government is the answer.

incredible
written by Dr. J, November 24, 2009
I don't think I can read anymore of this idiocy. This administration spends the US into oblivion prior to healthcare- Then healthcare will cost $25 trillion over the 10 years (2016-2026) after it is fully implemented. Taxes will go through the roof. Our children will owe more to China than can ever be paid. Then this guy suggests the US needs to be competitive by making green products. Give me a break. Take an economics 101 course before spewing this bilge.
By the way, healthcare is available to virtually every American. Health insurance is not. Health insurance will not improve the health of anyone. Health insurance is financial insurance so that a major breakdown in one's health will not totally wipe out someone's savings.
LOL!!!!
written by Mark Osgatharp, November 24, 2009
Leave it to a Mercer "ethics professor" to turn the giving of thanks into a Democrat partisan/green diatribe! LOL!

Maybe if all the rich elitist Universities in this country would divest themselves and bestow all their riches to feed the poor they could make a real difference to the hungry.

If Mr. Gushy wants a real ethical issue about which to rant, let him rant about the state lotteries which rape the poor in then name of funding education.

LOL!!!

Mark Osgatharp
Wynne, Arkansas

footdragging?
written by Bobby McCord, November 25, 2009
What about the Democratic footdragging on saving the sanctity of marriage or are you concerned about the rights of homosexuals to live a life that God calls an abomination. What about the Democrats foot dragging on saving the lives of the unborn. The democrats could have given health care insurance to everyone in America with the money they have spent in the last 12 months 5 times over. I am more woriied about our country standing for Christ and what is right, than I am about the economy, comfort, and even the health of it's citizens.
...
written by jbird, November 29, 2009
Well said, as usual, Dr. Gushee. I'm amazed that you have such a dedicated cadre of 'fans'.

Strong agree with 'Mark' about lotteries--but would 'Mark' support legislators who vote for higher taxes for state services? And let's add 'rich corporations' to the 'elitist Universities' 'Mark' calls to divest themselves of funds to feed the hungry. Could those obscene Wall Street 'bonuses' not be put to better use? We all stand under the judgment of Matt. 25:31-46.
help
written by Bobby McCord, November 30, 2009
The best help we can give to the world around us is to give them Jesus. The church doesn't have and will never have the resouces to feed clothe and provide healthcare to everyone in America and by the way neither does the Government. When we help those in our community, it must always be with the goals of Glorifying God and reaching them for Christ. If those are not our goals we are simply a benevolence club instead of the church. I believing in helping but I also believe the church of America is spending to much of our precious time and money enabling the world to continue to live ungodly lifestyles. America's biggest need is not Healthcare it is Christ. Remember a socialist government is an atheistic government. "There are six days in which man should work", "teach them any who will not work should not eat"
Gushee worng this time
written by Slick, November 30, 2009
More often than not, I generaly agree with a good bit of what David Gushee writes but for him to ignore the fact that at least half the nations is opposed to oBAMacare causes him to miss the mark this time. Those above who wrote of the costs involved are correct. But those who demand that universities and those who "have" divest themselves of what they have earned are spouting noting more than Marxist socialism. That's wrong. Why do shallow-minded, poorly educated, simpleton non-thinkers always want to drag in abortion an homosexuality as if those are the only two ills of our country? And state lotteries are noting more than a voluntary tax. There's nothing unbiblical about them. It's people who play them and if all their money is lost to a lottery, it's no different that all of one's money being lost in the stock market. This country will always have something that someone wants to whine about, so it will never be perfect. Time spent in God's word rather than spending time complaining about homosexuality, the lottery, or abortion is time better spent.
to slick
written by Bobby McCord, November 30, 2009
I am glad you are so educated and refined culturally.You really are slick. I happen to think that the murder of unborn children is important. I believe the abomination of homosexuallity that is now promoted as a legal civil right is one of the biggest dangers to our freedom to worship, preach God's Word, and secure what God says about family. Anyone who believes that the lottery is anything other than state sponsored gambling is the simpleton who simply refuses to submit to God's Word. You would feel more at home writing on the A.C.L.U. web site. I'll be praying for your salvation.
One Rich, Elitist University attender's views
written by Chester Frito, November 30, 2009
Bravo commentators! I love how these comments have digressed from a discussion about Government involvement in healthcare and social-justice issues to a jibe against homosexuality and how "homosexual rights" impede on our freedoms to gather and worship together. Bravo!
Can you help me?
written by FWN, November 30, 2009
To Bobby McCord:

I have a problem, and, after reading several of your posts, I think that maybe you can help me.

You see, I own a small business, one that most years barely turns a profit. I furnish health insurance to my employees, a bare-bones policy, but one that last year cost me $126,000. The premiums on that policy have increased an average of 15% per year over the last 10 years, even though we’ve had no significant claims. I provide this insurance because I take seriously the things that Jesus Christ taught during his earthly ministry. I don’t have much, but what I do have, I try to share.

My problem is that I don’t know how much longer I’ll be able to continue this policy, and my friends in the business world are all facing the same problem. I hear what you’re saying that we simply can’t afford health care, but I also remember that the last administration ran up a tab of over $5 trillion in tax cuts for the rich and a couple of questionable mid-east wars. I guess it all depends on what your priorities are, especially considering what Christ taught (Matthew 6:19-21).

Every time I think about dropping my employees’ coverage, I’m haunted by that passage, as well as those in Micah 6:6-8, Matthew 25:33-45, and especially Matthew 22:37-40.

You see, I don’t have the advantage of your inerrant Bible, just my old Scofield KJV which I’ve studied and tried to live by for over 60 years. Since you seem to be so well-versed in your inerrant scripture, I’m sure you can give me passages that will disprove those that haunt me, and to help me justify my selfishness.

I have always believed that my faith should inform my politics, but you seem to have mastered it the other way round. Maybe that’s my problem.

Can you help?
FRITO
written by Mark Osgatharp, November 30, 2009
Mr. Frito,

You said,

"I love how these comments have digressed from a discussion about Government involvement in healthcare....."

The original digression was from the dishonest headline "Giving thanks in a troubled land" - to left wing political carping.

Mark Osgatharp
Wynne, Arkansas
help
written by Bobby McCord, December 01, 2009
Here is your help. Drop the insurance, divide what you are paying for it and add it to your employees salaries and let them decide how they want to fund their own health care instead of turning your responsibity over to the government which ultimately means turning it over to every other taxpayer, including me. I don't want government intervention in my healthcare and I imagine some of your employees don't either. You bought this horse so ride it instead of looking to Obama to save the day. Do what you think is right for your employees without sticking it to everyone else.
more help
written by Bobby McCord, December 01, 2009
I know you need to ease your consience but don't pretend to help your employees by putting the burden on the rest of the taxpayers. If this government option passes, employers like you all over the nation will force their employees on it, pocket the money they have been paying for insurance, and claim that they are doing them a favor.If every employer who provides health insurance for their employees would drop the insurance, pay the money to the employees, by the way its their money, and let them use it the way choose, our economy would experience a real stimulus and insurance companies would truly have to compete for every individual's business. The government has never fixed anything. Look at social secirity, look at medicare, look at the postal service, look at the immigration department. The only thing the government does well is take our money and spend us into a debt that my grandchildren wont be able to pay if this country even lasts that long. Use a little common sense if the culture and media hasn't already robbed you of that too.
I'm disappointed
written by FWN, December 01, 2009
Bobby McCord:

I’m disappointed; I asked for a spiritual answer to the very real problem of how a Christian should respond to physical human need, and all you gave me were Republican Party talking points.

No matter.

You have conclusively demonstrated that your personal politics do control your faith. I grieve for you (Romans 14:10-12).

Good day, sir.
explain
written by Bobby McCord, December 01, 2009
Do you want me to tell you where in the Bible it says that it is ok for you to save the money you are paying your employees for insurance and shift that burden to the other taxpayers? The Bible says "render unto Ceasar what is Ceasar's" It doesnt say render unto Ceasar what you should do yourself. If the repuclican party is the party that stands for life, family, and smaller government, that is where I stand. One day you will answer for why you thought the economy was more important than life, family, Christian liberty, and standards set forth in God's Word. Explain to me one thing the government has taken over that prospered for anyone other than politicians.
...
written by robber, December 07, 2009
I just don't get how an adult, with years of real-world experience (?), could ever look to the government for solutions. Bureaucracies are not in the business of providing solutions. They are in the business of taking and keeping their power. This health-care bill is about bureaucratic power. Washington politicians are not acting in our best interests, neither Democrats or Republicans. The answer, no matter what your question is, does not lie in Washington. Why can't we move past the politics and start taking our country back? If you see a neighbor in trouble, help them. Feed them, clothe them. Pray for the lost, the hungry and the poor. Remember, they shall inherit the earth.
Do not look to Washington (or your state capitol) to do this for you. They cannot physically do this; nor do they want to do this. This is our responsibility.

Solutions? I look to the words of Charles Krauthammer, see this article:

http://www.stltoday.com/stltoday/news/columnists.nsf/charleskrauthammer/story/8AFA7DFFD71B8C238625767A0001043C?OpenDocument

Krauthammer cites the unknown and unintended ramifications of this huge bill before Congress. Even the ones who have read it and will vote for it have no idea what it will mean years from now. Krauthammer points to three simple ideas that everyone can understand and will go a long way in making health coverage cheaper and more accessible. Tort reform, interstate purchasing and taxing employee benefits.

It is the job of government to keep us free so we can help others; not to do the helping for us. We need less government in our lives, not more. Gushee can keep spouting this trash if he wants, but I will never stop responding to it. It's garbage, complete garbage. He and ABP should be ashamed.
finally
written by Bobby McCord, December 11, 2009
Great post robber. Finally someone who has not been brainwashed by the retoric of the left. As Christians, we should stand for each other and those in our community who truly need help. Our church takes care of the members and helps those in the community but we are good stewards. We dont use God's money to help and enable people to continue to live ungodly. Sometimes the best help you can give a person is to say no. Our government is not a good steward of the resources it has. It pays people not to work, it pays people to have illigitimate children, it pays people who come here illegally, and it pays the politicians a part of everything it pays to others. All I want the government to do is leave me alone.
to: McCord
written by robber, December 15, 2009
Then I suggest we all pray for our children and grandchildren. Their world will be worse then we can even imagine. Come Jesus, come.

Readers alone are responsible for the content of the comments they post here. The comments are subject to the site’s terms and conditions of use and do not necessarily reflect the opinion or approval of the ABP News. Readers whose comments violate the terms of use may have their comments removed or all of their content blocked from viewing by other users without notification.
Write comment
You must be logged in to leave a comment. Login | Register
busy
 
< Prev   Next >
Copyright © 2007-2010 Associated Baptist Press, All Rights Reserved.