New Voice Media | Associated Baptist Press
     
 
Saturday, July 31, 2010
Home arrow News arrow Most religiously conservative states have highest teen birth rates
 
Most religiously conservative states have highest teen birth rates Print E-mail
By Bob Allen   
Thursday, September 17, 2009

PHILADELPHIA (ABP) -- Teenage birth rates tend to be higher in states that are more religiously conservative, possibly because communities in those places discourage contraception, according to a national study.

An article in the open-access journal Reproductive Health reported a high correlation between births to teenagers and states where high percentages of the population subscribe to conservative religious views, such as, "There is only one way to interpret the teachings of my religion" or, "Scripture should be taken literally, word for word."

Drexel University psychiatrist Joseph Strayhorn said he and co-author Jillian Strayhorn were "astonished" by the strong correlation between teenage births and religious beliefs, even after the figures were adjusted for other factors like differing abortion rates and income levels between states.

The authors compared information on religiosity from the 2007 U.S. Religious Landscapes Survey by the Pew Forum on Religion and Public Life with teen-birth and abortion statistics that came from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

Mississippi, where more than half of the population self-identifies as being Baptist, topped the list for both conservative religious beliefs and teen-birth rates. At the bottom of the list, New Hampshire ranked last in teen pregnancy and trailed only Vermont in religiosity.

Strayhorn said it would be a mistake to apply the statewide totals to individuals and draw a conclusion like "religious teens get pregnant more often," but he said the findings do suggest "that religious communities in the U.S. are more successful in discouraging the use of contraception among their teenagers than they are in discouraging sexual intercourse itself."

Strayhorn admitted that a preference for abstinence-only sex education in conservative communities is just one plausible explanation. He said one factor might be that people in more liberal states tend to delay marriage, while teen marriage is more common in the South.

Strayhorn also said that on an individual level, some teen pregnancies are desirable and that some teen parents carry out their responsibilities very well. But since studies have found children of teenage mothers tend to have higher rates of several unfavorable mental-health outcomes than other children, he said in general that "it is probably true that public policies or cultural practices that reduce the overall rate of teen births are, other things equal, desirable."

The article is set to appear in an upcoming issue of Reproductive Health, the official journal of the Geneva Foundation for Medical Education and Research. It is also affiliated with the International Association for Maternal and Neonatal Health.

-30-

This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it  is senior writer for Associated Baptist Press. 

 





Reddit!Del.icio.us!Google!Live!Facebook!Slashdot!Technorati!StumbleUpon!Spurl!Newsvine!Blinklist!Furl!Fark!Yahoo!Ma.gnolia!Free social bookmarking plugins and extensions for Joomla! websites!
Comments (12)Add Comment
...
written by ABP Reader, September 17, 2009
This is quite interesting. I'll be interested to see the full report on the study when it appears.
demographical differences might account for the difference as well as overlooking marital status
written by Xenophon, September 17, 2009
The study seems to overlook the demographical differences between such states as Mississippi on one hand and Vermont and New Hampshire on the other.

The study also apparently fails to take marital status into account. I used to live in Mississippi and I know from first-hand observation that a lot of teens there get married and have children. The problem is not teen pregnancy per se but out-of-wedlock births.
correction
written by Xenophon, September 17, 2009
I should have said just above that the problem is not simply teen pregnancy but teens or anyone else having sex out-of-wedlock. It is especially problematic when a pregnancy results from illicit sex.

Sex education should include discussions of the psychological damage done to anyone having sex outside of marriage as well as the physical risks that are growing in their frequency.
Conservative States' Teen Birth Rates
written by mightyfowl, September 17, 2009
It'll be interesting to see the full study results, if any are available. The difference could be in the resistance to Public-School sex education in those "conservative" states, coupled with a lousy job being done by the churches in those states. I've thought for years that we've done a terrible job .. I've asked teens if they felt they received a satisfactory education in those matters, for years, and not 1 in 50 ever said they did.

Shame on us.
...
written by pjerwin, September 17, 2009
Here you have the first reason these findings must be scrutinized more deeply:
...a high correlation between births to teenagers and states where high percentages of the population subscribe to conservative religious views, such as, "There is only one way to interpret the teachings of my religion" or, "Scripture should be taken literally, word for word."
Notwithstanding the prima facia fact that these are not "conservative" religious views, but views of legalistic fundamentalism, how many states would boast a high percentage of the population subscribing to these views?

And what kind garbage is THIS?
Strayhorn also said that on an individual level, some teen pregnancies are desirable...
Teenage pregnancies are desireable? Unless were talking about a different subset of young ladies than is implied, that's a pretty outrageous statement.

The implication of the presentation of this study is that they're talking about high school teenagers. That's different than including ALL teenagers, that is 17, 18 and 19 year old high school graduates. Including those young ladies in this study would GREATLY skew the interpretation of the results.
The Ethnic Factor
written by Mark Osgatharp, September 17, 2009
The south is the most religiously conservative area of the country as well as the area with the highest non-white population. Whereas blacks and hispanics have a higher rate of teen pregnancy than whites, and whereas these three groups represent three divergent religious and ethnic cultures, any study dealing with teen pregnancy and religion that does not take the the ethnic factor into consideration is fundamentally flawed and consequently worthless.

It should be noted that Hispanics have the highest rate of teen pregnancy and are also the most consistently Roman Catholic demographic group. This would indicate that, if there is a correlation between religion and teen pregnancy, it is tied more to Roman Catholicism specifically than to religious conservatism in general.

Mark Osgatharp
Wynne, Arkansas

Mark Osgatharp
Wynne, Arkansas
...
written by pjerwin, September 17, 2009
Teen pregnancy: did your study lump ALL teens together, including teens who've already graduated from high school?
Teen
written by Big Daddy Weave, September 18, 2009
The study is about teenagers.

Neither the AP or ABP story mentions "high school."

A "teen" is by definition someone whose age number ends in "teen"

13-19.

By the way, many many many high schoolers who get pregnant during their senior year of high school are age 19 when they give birth.
Race Factor
written by Slick, September 18, 2009
Mark's comment about the article not addressing the race of the pregnant teenagers is exactly right. While there is teenage pregnace in all races, in the South it is far more prevalent among Blacks than Whites. That's not a condemnation of any race--it's just a fact.

But it's still an interesting finding. Unfortunately, simply looking at numbers often misses the greater picture. The researchers, as refelcted in this article, seem to equate more widespread religion with behavior and expect more religious states to have a greater dose of the so-called morality factor among its people. Obviously a faulty assumption.
Pastor in the Mississippi Delta
written by Jon Doler, September 18, 2009
The high birth rate among teenagers in the Mississippi Delta is due to many factors other than religious conservatism or churches doing a poor job. It is tied to poverty, family life, values, education and other factors such as the lack of individual responsibilty. This article is so far from the real world of the Mississippi Delta. Those who have a lack of understanding of the problem such as the writer of this story and those who have simple answers to the situation are welcome and encouraged to move here in one of our many vacant houses and help us address the issues at hand in the name of Christ.

...
written by pjerwin, September 18, 2009
Thanks for the help, BDW! You're the man!
...
written by KT2005, September 19, 2009
less abortions = more births

Readers alone are responsible for the content of the comments they post here. The comments are subject to the site’s terms and conditions of use and do not necessarily reflect the opinion or approval of the ABP News. Readers whose comments violate the terms of use may have their comments removed or all of their content blocked from viewing by other users without notification.
Write comment
You must be logged in to leave a comment. Login | Register
busy
 
< Prev   Next >
Copyright © 2007-2010 Associated Baptist Press, All Rights Reserved.